Investing vs. Speculating

20 October by Joe Byrne in Investments

Investing vs. Speculating

Bitcoin is the latest ‘hot’ trend but is it worth investing in? With any investment opportunity, it is important to make the distinction between investing and speculating. In simple terms, speculators are trying to out-smart the markets while investors simply participate in the markets. The investment time horizon is also a very important factor as speculation tends to be over the short-term while investing is over the long-term.

Speculating is purchasing an asset to capitalise on market inefficiencies, in the hope it will become more valuable at a future date. It is an attempt to profit from a short-term market move rather than attempting to profit from the underlying financial attributes of the asset, such as dividends, interest income or capital gains.

Warren Buffet is regarded as one of the most respected investors of our generation. He was inspired by the work of Professor Benjamin Graham of the Columbia Business School in New York City. Professor Benjamin Graham, along with Professor David Dodd, attempted a precise definition of investing and speculating in their seminal work Security Analysis (1934). 

“An investment operation is one which, upon thorough analysis, promises safety of principal and a satisfactory return. Operations not meeting these requirements are speculative”.


 Bitcoin is a very hotly discussed topic in the financial press these days. A question that keeps coming up; is this a good investment or is this just media hype built on speculation?

Here is a good summation of Bitcoin from Platinum International’s December 2017 quarterly report;

“Some argue that the structure of Bitcoin is an exact replica of a Ponzi Scheme. Nobody can see Bitcoin or make anything out of it and there is no utility value holding Bitcoin (unlike, say gold, which is used to make jewellery and has some limited industrial uses). Bitcoin generates no income, and an owner of Bitcoin can only make money by selling the Bitcoin at a higher price to another investor. Bitcoin buyers are attracted by the very high appreciation apparently on offer, and the continuation of the scheme is dependent upon current holders continuing to hold. Encouraging holding, there are some barriers to moving Bitcoin held off an exchange onto an exchange, such as slow transaction time and high transaction costs, making selling difficult. To cap things off, the whole process is facilitated by the exchanges, which act as a cashed-up manager of the scheme, pumping out unregulated advertising promoting the wonderful returns on offer.

The Future of Bitcoin is unclear, but it is unlikely to become a medium of exchange in its current form, and further regulation is likely on the horizon.”

In addition to the above listed failings, the future of Bitcoin is dependent on future regulation which therefore puts Bitcoin firmly into the ‘Speculation’ camp and therefore not part of the Lifetime Investment offerings.


Investment Philosophy

Lifetime has adopted an evidenced based, risk managed investment philosophy. This means we look to gain market access in a cost-effective manner whilst limiting the amount of risk our clients take. We look at both the risk and return side of the equation for our investors, and do not follow a ‘returns at any cost’ philosophy (which rules out Bitcoin). Our job is to ensure our investors are adequately compensated for the investment risks they take, which is the essence of Modern Portfolio Theory.

It is our job at Lifetime to make sure our clients are comfortable with how their portfolios are being invested, in-line with their values and beliefs.

If you have any questions regarding this, or your investment portfolio, please speak to your financial adviser.



Article by Joe Byrne, BA, AFA - Read more

by Lifetime

You’re sitting in your favourite restaurant, feeling famished. The waiter arrives and reads out a long list of mouth-watering specials. Yet the moment he walks away, you find you can recall only the last item on the list. Congratulations, you’ve been struck by the recency effect.

by Lifetime

One of the most persistent debates in the investment industry is whether investors are better to use passive or active managed funds. With strong advocates on both sides of this debate, it may seem like an obscure discussion. However, for investors, long-term performance data tells a conspicuous story.